Blending vs Juicing: Which Is Better?

It’s the classic, plant-based health question — which is better, blending or juicing?

The answer… both.

Both blended smoothies and freshly extracted vegetable juices offer exponentially better nutrient absorption than whole, raw foods.

But they are definitely not the same thing. And don’t let an infomercial tell you otherwise!

Although some people refer to high-powered blenders as “juicers”, blenders retain the fiber, whereas juicers are specially designed to separate the fiber, leaving only a liquid packed with nutrients.

The difference is, when the juice is separated from the pulp, you can easily consume a much larger volume of vegetables than you could by drinking a smoothie containing pulp.

For example, if you blend a smoothie, you might include up to 7 leaves of kale along with some fruit. Those 7 leaves of kale will yield only about 1.5 oz of juice.

Since we can easily drink an 8 oz serving of juice without fiber, the volume of concentrated nutrients available in 8 oz of vegetable juice would be much greater than a large smoothie containing just 1.5 oz of juice.

Drinking fresh, fiber-free juice (particularly on an empty stomach) eliminates strain on the digestive tract because the juicer has already done most of the digestion work for you, having separated the fiber from the juice. Without fiber to digest, the juice can be efficiently shuttled into your bloodstream within 30 minutes.

The beauty of this efficiency is that the nutrients have practically no time to degrade. The best vitamin and mineral complement to a whole food diet is plenty of freshly extracted vegetable juice.

Although juicing is great for delivering concentrated nutrients to the cellular level, it does not replace need for salads and smoothies. A well-rounded diet of whole foods packed with fiber is still foundational to a healthy diet.

Smoothies, blended soups, and blended salads are excellent ways to get a variety of raw, whole foods with fiber into your daily routine. Because they are filling and substantial due to their fiber content, they help curb the temptation to eat too much cooked food.

And contrary to what some would say, enzyme action is not necessarily better in juice than a smoothie — we have proof!

Hallelujah Acres Research Director Dr. Michael Donaldson compared the enzyme content of freshly extracted juice to the enzyme content in a smoothie.

Why the debate? Some say that the heat and air involved in whipping up a smoothie degrades the enzymes.

But Dr. Donaldson found the opposite to be true!

“The blender did not cause any loss of enzymatic activity,” he said after comparing the two. “In fact, there was a slight increase in enzymatic activity in the blender. This may be due to the blender releasing more enzymes from inside of the cells because it chops vegetable cells much finer than can be accomplished by the grinding action of a juicer.”

How’s that for a surprise ending!

Again, if we consume blended foods at meal times and fiber-free juices on an empty stomach, we are receiving the best of both worlds.

[quote]Do you prefer juices or smoothies?
Scroll below the related articles to comment![/quote]

Check Also

A Beginner’s Guide to Taking on the 60-Day Challenge

A Beginner’s Guide to Taking on the 60-Day Challenge

Some of the most popular foods in the American diet will age the body and ...

10 comments

  1. Marcia Zimmerman

    I prefer smoothies but enjoy juices as well. They both have been an excellent help to me finding solutions to my health issues.

    • The thing I like about smoothies is you don’t have all the clean up like you do when you juice. I know both are vitally important. I also use the carrot powder on the days when I can’t juice.

  2. Both juicing and blending are an important part of my routine. My breakfast usually consists of a green smoothie; lunch is a blended (occasionally chopped) salad, and my day wouldn’t be complete without vegetable juices and BarleyMax. My cells are very happy! 🙂 Thanks Ann and Paul for the great article!

    • I agree with you on this. I love both also. I like to start out with Carrot juice first thing on an empty stomach, this is when you can benefit the most from the nutrients.

  3. I see on the hallelujah diet that you say to start out with a green smoothie and then a couple hours later the carrot juice.
    Would it be okay if I started out with the carrot juice first and then the smoothie?

  4. Do to me healing from candadia I cannot do the sugars. I use to have an apple in my juice and a banana in my breakfast smoothie. Well I can’t do that. So I do the barley max on an empty stomach in the morning and do a blended salad for breakfast. It seems to work for me and I enjoy it. Sometimes I desire something sweet and the solution for me is coconut milk kefir I have learn to make myself or a small portion of nuts and seeds. It works!

  5. I prefere smoothies. Juicing gives you a lot of waste (pulp). With blending you have little or nothing to throw away.

  6. we both have 2 ounces of wheatgrass juice first thing each morning for the past 3 1/2 years never miss and have a great belief in the health benefits of freshly juiced home grown wheat grass with TLC, each to their own if you genuinely believe in what you are doing.

  7. Great article but I prefer juices over smoothies and blended raw savory soups

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *